What’s the Ideal Corporate Vacation Policy?

Category: Career | Opinion
October 1, 2024

Rest is more important than we’d ever imagined as a way to balance our overwhelmingly busy modern lives. I’ve been researching various forms of rest for years and even quit my full-time job in order to try some of the things out that I’ve discovered. My conclusion in a nutshell? If you’re working full-time in the United States, you don’t get nearly enough rest each day, week, or year. (That might be the obvious statement of the year.) Well, let’s change that, shall we? Many of us are switching jobs or taking time off in order to secure better benefits and make some real changes in our lives. So, what can you look out for as you make your next big career move? Let’s examine in-depth one of my favorite corporate benefits: vacation time, and discuss what the ideal corporate vacation policy really looks like.

If you’re working full-time in the United States, you don’t get nearly enough rest each day, week, or year.

How Much Rest Do We Need?

Rest isn’t really a topic out for debate anymore. All of the literature agrees on this general fact: we can only deeply focus for around 3-4 hours per day and then we become much less productive. If you want to be performing at your best, an ideal schedule would include focusing deeply on your most important task(s) for 3-4 hours per day, spending 1-2 hours on non-essential items (like emails and meetings), and taking at least 2 days off per week. Spend the rest of the time on relaxing activities such as walking, socializing, reading, and anything else that helps you recover your energy. Many of history’s most productive people did exactly this, whether they were famous violinists, Benjamin Franklin, or Charles Darwin.

If you want to be performing at your best, an ideal schedule would include focusing deeply on your most important task(s) for 3-4 hours per day, spending 1-2 hours on non-essential items (like emails and meetings), and taking at least 2 days off per week.

To learn more about the above topic, I’ve got a few book suggestions for you. You can find my book summaries and links to find the books here:

Traditional Vacation Policies

Most corporate jobs in the United States offer employees a set amount of time off for vacations. It can be as low as nothing (yikes!), but typically starts at two weeks and goes up to 4-5 weeks off per year, plus holidays. Sometimes that vacation time includes sick leave and time to care for loved ones and sometimes sick leave is separate.

Some offices are highly rigid and require that you ask for each and every day you take off. Others are highly flexible, trusting their employees to generally work 40 hours per week, it doesn’t matter which ones. I’ve always worked in tech and I’ve always had highly flexible policies. That meant that the company trusted me enough to allow me to work remotely sometimes and take time off in the middle of the day to run appointments without using my vacation time. I would never work somewhere that wasn’t flexible. Full stop. If I ever had to ask my manager for time off versus just taking it when I know the team can support my absence, I would be looking for another job immediately.

Unlimited Vacation Policies

More and more, particularly at tech companies, we are now seeing “unlimited” vacation policies. You can have as many days off each year as you want, as long as you get your work done! Sounds pretty good, doesn’t it? I’ve worked at two companies with unlimited vacation policies and loved it. I no longer had to work around a specific set of days each year, worry about time off for appointments, or anything else. Taking vacation days is really important. I always took the amount that I needed and still got my work done. It’s also great for the company as they don’t have to pay out hefty vacation balances when an employee leaves.

Unfortunately, what happens at many of the companies with unlimited policies is that people end up working more, not less. If the company culture is one in which employees are working around the clock anyway, checking email during vacation, and bragging about their hours, unlimited vacation policies can actually cause employees to take fewer days of vacation. What it really comes down to at that point is culture. If the executive and management teams take a lot of vacation (i.e. set a good example), then employees will too. If they don’t, then employees tend to follow suit.

Despite this trend, I still very much prefer having an unlimited vacation policy. I want to work at companies that trust me to get my job done and let me take the time off that I need and deserve throughout the year.

The Ideal Vacation Policy

Here’s what I think is actually the best vacation policy. Ideally, most companies would have an unlimited vacation policy with a minimum number of days that each employee has to take off. The minimum, in my opinion, should be at least three weeks. Two weeks is way too little for anyone to recharge. Three is probably on the lighter side, but it is a minimum, so employees should be encouraged to take many more days than that. With a minimum explicitly stated, a culture of rest is baked into the employee handbook and no one has to wonder if their vacation time looks excessive compared to everyone else. If I ever started a company, this would be our vacation policy and the minimum would be a lot more than three weeks.

I’m curious whether you agree with my “ideal vacation policy”? Post a comment and let’s continue to chat about it!

Search the Blog

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog. We will never share your email.

About Amber Field

Amber has over 20 years of experience working in the software industry with agile software teams and specializes in creating efficient, happy teams & clients while helping them scale, execute, and work / live intentionally.
Get to know Amber →

Check Amber Out On:

Browse Posts by Category

Recent Posts

Exit Interview: A Book Review

Exit Interview: A Book Review

I recently read Exit Interview: The Life and Death of My Ambitious Career by Kristi Coulter. I picked it up because the title resonated with me. I, too, have had an ambitious tech career and just recently semi-retired, pulling back to teach and run programs at my alma mater, the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Coulter’s book was funny, interesting, and, above all, kind of PTSD-inducing if you’re in tech and especially if you’re a woman in tech.

read more
A Different Kind of Power: Why Jacinda Ardern’s Version of Leadership Matters

A Different Kind of Power: Why Jacinda Ardern’s Version of Leadership Matters

I just finished A Different Kind of Power: A Memoir by Jacinda Ardern, New Zealand’s Prime Minister from 2017 to 2023. At a moment when the political world feels particularly bleak, Ardern’s book feels different. It’s full of hope (and good decisions). Her tenure as New Zealand’s Prime Minister shows us that a person can hold the highest office in a country and still be, unmistakably and unapologetically, a human being, a woman, and a mom.

read more
Stick Together: What the Women’s Suffrage Movement Can Teach Us About Politics Right Now

Stick Together: What the Women’s Suffrage Movement Can Teach Us About Politics Right Now

I’ve been working on a new book for women trying to kick ass in a male-centric world and I’m in the developmental editing stages right now. I just got through my final chapter and I love it so, darn much. The chapter is called: “Stick Together: How To Stop Undermining Other Women & Get Things Done Together”. Historically, our failure to stick together has cost us decades of progress. Here’s just one example.

read more